The facts › Keeping our stars

Does a salary cap force teams to trade their stars?

In capped leagues it happens often, sometimes right after a title. Tampa Bay lost key players after back-to-back Stanley Cups. Boston traded Jrue Holiday and Kristaps Porzingis a year after its 2024 NBA title, and its president said the payroll limit was why. The Chiefs and Rams moved star players to manage their NFL caps.

Think about the player you'd never want your team to lose: the homegrown star, the one whose jersey you own. In leagues with a salary cap, fans watch that player leave all the time, often because the team ran out of room under the cap rather than because anyone wanted him gone.

What it has looked like in other leagues

LeagueTeamWhenWhat happened
NHLTampa Bay Lightning2021, after back-to-back Stanley CupsLost Yanni Gourde in the expansion draft and Blake Coleman in free agency, and waived Tyler Johnson. Their general manager said the cap is designed in part to make it harder for teams to sustain success.
NHLChicago Blackhawks2010, after winning the Stanley CupDescribed by the Associated Press as the first Cup winner to face a cap crunch, the team moved several players from its title roster that summer.
NBABoston Celtics2025, a year after the 2024 titleTraded Jrue Holiday and Kristaps Porzingis to get under the league's "second apron" payroll limit. President Brad Stevens: "The second apron is why."
NFLKansas City Chiefs2022Traded star receiver Tyreek Hill to Miami. Coach Andy Reid said the team tried to keep him "at a certain cost," and the trade cleared more than $18 million in cap space.
NFLLos Angeles Rams2023, a year after winning the Super BowlMore than $14 million over the cap, the Rams traded All-Pro cornerback Jalen Ramsey and parted with Bobby Wagner, Leonard Floyd and Allen Robinson that spring.

Cap pressure is rarely the only factor. In Tyreek Hill's case, contract talks and a jump in the receiver market also played a part. But in each case, staying under the limit was part of the reason the team gave or reporters documented.

Why a cap makes this happen

A cap fixes how much a team can pay its whole roster. Winning makes players more valuable, so their next contracts cost more. A championship team often can't afford to keep everyone who won it, and has to choose who goes. See how a cap makes pay zero-sum.

How baseball works today

MLB has no hard cap. A team that wants to keep its core together can, if its owner is willing to pay, with a luxury tax on payrolls above a set level. Teams still let players go for many reasons, but "cap reasons" isn't one of them. Under MLB's proposed $258.2 million cap, every team at or near the limit would have cap reasons too.

What it could mean for us

If your team built a winner, would you rather it had the choice to keep that roster together, or a rule that might force it apart? Losing that choice is one of the trade-offs fans in capped leagues live with every offseason.

Sources

  1. ESPN: Why the Lightning are the most impressive champions of the NHL cap era (2021)
  2. AP via Fox Sports: Several Stanley Cup winners breaking up championship core
  3. CBS Boston: Celtics' second apron trades of Porzingis and Holiday
  4. Fox Sports: Why did the Celtics trade Jrue Holiday and Kristaps Porzingis?
  5. CBS Sports: Andy Reid says Chiefs tried to keep Tyreek Hill at a certain cost
  6. KSHB: Salary cap management underscores Chiefs' decision to trade Tyreek Hill
  7. ESPN: Biggest questions after the Rams trade Jalen Ramsey to the Dolphins (2023)
  8. Sports Illustrated: Rams trade, cut and sign moves around Ramsey, Floyd, Robinson

Last updated