The facts › Keeping our stars

How a salary cap affects player pay: it makes it zero-sum

A hard cap fixes the total a team can pay its players. A fixed total turns pay into a zero-sum game: every extra dollar one player earns comes out of what his teammates can earn. Revenue the team makes beyond the cap stays with the owners. MLB's proposal would also count player benefits inside its $258.2 million cap.

A fixed pie

Without a cap, a team that grows its revenue can pay its stars more and still keep the rest of the roster. With a hard cap, the pie is fixed. A new contract for the ace means less for the shortstop, the bullpen and the next rookie. A cap doesn't share the money. It shares the limit.

Who keeps the rest

When a capped team's revenue rises faster than the cap, the extra goes to the owner. Keeping the extra is the point of a cap from an owner's view: it makes player costs predictable while revenue keeps growing.

What it could mean for us

We could lose the chance to see our team keep a homegrown star and add free agents in the same winter. In capped leagues, fan favorites are routinely let go for "cap reasons." Baseball fans rarely have to hear that phrase today. See the cases from other leagues.

Sources

  1. theScore: MLB proposal details
  2. Sports Illustrated: Tony Clark calls a cap institutionalized collusion

Last updated