Salary caps and work stoppages: a timeline of baseball and the other leagues
Each league adopted a cap to answer its own moment: the NBA in 1984 after years of teams losing money, the NFL in 1994 as a trade for free agency, and the NHL in 2005 after cancelling a whole season. MLB has never had one. Its owners last pushed for a cap in 1994, and the strike that followed cancelled the World Series and cost the sport a large share of its fans.
Every time this fight comes around, someone says baseball should "just do what the other leagues do." Here's what the other leagues actually did, side by side with baseball's own history, and what each fight cost the fans in the stands.
- 1876MLB
The National League is founded. 2026 is its 150th season, and baseball has never had a salary cap.
- 1972MLB
Baseball's first strike wipes out the first week and a half of the season.
- 1972Fans
Football passes baseball as Americans' favorite sport to watch in Gallup's poll, a lead it has held ever since.
- 1976MLB
Players win free agency. Baseball gets it without accepting a cap in return.
- 1981MLB
A midseason strike costs about a third of the season.
- 1984NBA
The NBA adopts a soft salary cap, with many exceptions, after years of teams losing money.
- 1994NFL
The NFL's hard cap begins. Owners accepted real free agency after losing in court, and players accepted a cap in return.
- 1994 to 95MLB
Owners insist on a salary cap the players never agreed to. Expecting owners to impose it once the season ended, players strike in August 1994 rather than accept it. The strike lasts 232 days and the World Series is cancelled for the first time in 90 years. In December, owners do impose the cap on their own, then end free agency and salary arbitration and bring in replacement players for spring training. The labor board finds the cap was imposed illegally, and on March 31, 1995, federal judge Sonia Sotomayor issues an injunction against the owners that ends the strike. The owners never get their cap.
- 1995Fans
The fans pay the price. Per-game attendance falls 20%, from 31,256 to 25,021. In Harris polls, the share of adults who follow MLB drops from 49% in May 1994 to 33% in June 1995, and 71% of those still following say they're less interested than before.
- 1996 to 97MLB
Instead of a cap, baseball adopts revenue sharing and a luxury tax on the highest payrolls.
- 1998 to 99NBA
An NBA lockout cuts the season to 50 games.
- 2004 to 05NHL
The NHL cancels its entire season to force a hard cap. The commissioner says a cap could let teams lower ticket prices.
- 2005 to 10Fans
NHL ticket prices dip 7.5% the first season back, then rise about 25% over the next five years.
- 2011NBA
Another NBA lockout cuts the season to 66 games.
- 2021NHL
After back-to-back Stanley Cups, Tampa Bay loses key players to stay under the cap. See more cases.
- 2021 to 22MLB
A 99-day lockout delays spring training and the start of the season.
- 2025NBA
A year after winning the title, Boston trades Jrue Holiday and Kristaps Porzingis to get under the league's payroll limit.
- 2026MLB
Attendance reaches 71.75 million, the fourth straight rise. Small-market Milwaukee beats Tampa Bay in the World Series. The labor deal expires December 1, with owners again demanding a cap.
Why each league got its cap
| League | Cap since | Type | Why it got one | Does that describe MLB today? |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| NBA | 1984 to 85 | Soft cap with many exceptions | Many teams losing money in the early 1980s | MLB attendance has risen four years running |
| NFL | 1994 | Hard cap | A trade: free agency for players, a cap for owners | MLB players have had free agency since 1976 |
| NHL | 2005 to 06 | Hard cap | Owners cancelled the 2004 to 05 season, citing losses | Ticket prices rose about 25% in the five years after |
| MLB | Never | Luxury tax and revenue sharing | n/a | Already has tools to restrain top spenders and share revenue |
Did the caps make those leagues better for fans?
Ticket prices didn't fall in any of them. The NHL's rose after its cap. All three capped leagues have also lost games to work stoppages over caps, and their fans now watch title teams get broken up to stay under the limit.
What 1994 tells us
The last time owners pushed this hard for a cap, fans lost a World Series and the sport lost a big share of its followers for years. Baseball recovered, grew, and has thrived for 150 years without a cap. So where does that leave us this time?
Sources
- Wikipedia: 1994 to 95 MLB strike
- Sports Illustrated Vault: A federal judge ended the strike (April 1995)
- CBS Sports: Remembering 1995's replacement players
- Gallup: Football's rise as a spectator sport (Gallup Vault)
- Spokesman-Review / Harris poll: Fan base going fast (July 1995)
- FiveThirtyEight: Do baseball's labor fights drive fans away?
- Wikipedia: 2021 to 22 MLB lockout
- CBS Sports: timeline of the 2021 to 22 lockout
- Yahoo Sports / Puck Daddy: NHL ticket prices after the 2005 cap
- ESPN: The Lightning and the NHL cap era (2021)
- CBS Boston: Celtics' second apron trades
- AP via NY1: MLB attendance rises for a fourth straight year (2026)
- Jackson Lewis: tracking 2026's pro sports labor agreements
Last updated