The facts › A fair shot for our team

Salary floor vs. salary cap: what each one does

A salary floor is a minimum each team must spend on player pay. A cap is a maximum. They solve different problems: a floor stops owners who won't spend, a cap stops owners who will. Neither requires the other. MLB's proposal pairs a $180.2 million floor with a $258.2 million cap, so the floor helps sell the cap.

Two different problems

Salary floorSalary cap
StopsOwners pocketing money instead of fielding a teamOwners spending to win
Who gainsFans of low-spending clubsOwners, through predictable player costs
MLB already hasNothing like it todayA luxury tax that already discourages top spending

MLB has proposed both together. Whether they have to come together is one of the biggest questions in this fight.

Is there another way to get there?

One idea that has nothing to do with a cap:

  1. Spend what you're given. Every dollar a club receives from the shared revenue pool must go to player salaries, employee salaries or spending that improves the fan experience, checked every year. Stadium improvements count. Land and real-estate development around the ballpark does not. Clubs that fall short pay the difference back into the pool.
  2. A floor in name only. A minimum payroll equal to a full 26-man roster at the league minimum: about $20.3M at today's $780,000 minimum, or $26M at the $1 million minimum MLB proposes for 2027.

Shared money is meant to make weaker clubs better for their fans. Requiring that it be spent on the team, its people or its fans stops it from becoming profit or real-estate funding, and it doesn't limit any team that wants to spend more.

What counts as fan-experience spending

CountsDoesn't count
Player salaries, and salaries for team and ballpark staff (ushers, concessions, grounds crew, scouts, coaches)Owner distributions and debt payments
Cheaper seats: a set number of affordable tickets every game, kids' and student pricingLand and real-estate development around the ballpark
Value concessions: a low-price menu every game, free waterHotels, offices and retail districts
Ballpark upgrades fans use: seating, shade, accessibility, restrooms, Wi-Fi, family areasLuxury suites and premium clubs that most fans can't buy into
Making games easier to watch: lower-cost local streaming and broadcast accessSpending on businesses outside baseball
Getting to the game: parking discounts, transit and shuttle partnerships
Community baseball: youth leagues, field repairs, school programs

Sources

  1. theScore: MLB's cap and floor proposal
  2. CBS Sports: MLB floated a $100M minimum and a $180M luxury-tax threshold

Last updated