The facts › A fair shot for our team
Does spending buy playoff trips and titles?
It helps, but it's far from the whole story. From 2017 to 2026, low-payroll Milwaukee, Cleveland and Tampa Bay made the playoffs 8, 7 and 6 times, while the high-payroll Angels never did. And the teams below MLB's proposed floor aren't short of money: they put 39% of their revenue into payroll, against about 53% for everyone else, and several were among baseball's most profitable clubs. Low spending with high profits points to ownership, not the lack of a cap.
Here's the answer, team by team. In the charts, colors show where MLB's proposal puts each team: cap list (would have to cut payroll), floor list (would have to add payroll) or in between.
First: a small market isn't the same as a low spender
These terms often get used as if they mean the same thing. They don't, and the difference matters for a cap.
- Market size (small or large market)
- How many people live around the team. It's set by geography, and no owner or labor deal can change it. New York is the biggest MLB metro area; Milwaukee is the smallest. MLB's numbers sort teams into just two groups, large and small, which can be misleading: San Francisco, the 13th-biggest metro, lands in the same "small market" group as Milwaukee, a metro about a third its size.
- Revenue
- Everything a team brings in: tickets, local TV, sponsors, plus its share of national TV and revenue-sharing money. A big market helps, but so do winning, the ballpark and the TV deal.
- Payroll (high or low spender)
- What a team pays its players. How much to pay is the owner's choice.
- Payroll share
- Payroll divided by revenue: how much of what comes in goes to the players.
A small market doesn't make a team a low spender, and a big market doesn't make it a big spender:
| Team | Market, as MLB counts it* | Metro size (of 27) | 2025 payroll (of 30) | Under MLB's plan |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Chicago White Sox | Large market | 3rd | 29th | Would have to add payroll |
| Washington Nationals | Large market | 8th | 24th | Would have to add payroll |
| Miami Marlins | Large market | 9th | 30th | Would have to add payroll |
| San Diego Padres | Small market | 18th | 6th | Would have to cut payroll |
| Kansas City Royals | Small market | 25th | 17th | No change |
When someone says "small-market teams can't compete," it's worth asking which one they mean: a team in a smaller city, or a team whose owner spends less.
*MLB doesn't publish which teams it counts as large market. Its claim that large-market teams won 90% of recent World Series only matches if "large market" means the 15 teams in the 12 biggest metro areas, so the 12 biggest metro areas are the line used here. See how we checked it. Metro size: US Census Bureau 2025 metro estimates (Toronto: Statistics Canada). Teams that share a metro, like the Mets and Yankees, share a rank, so there are 27 metro areas for 30 teams.
Do the teams that earn more spend more?
Mostly, yes. In the 2025 season, team revenue and payroll moved closely together (correlation 0.88, where 1 would be perfect).
But how much of their money do they spend on players?
This is where the teams split. The teams on MLB's floor list put 39% of their revenue into payroll on average. Everyone else put in about 53%.
You'd expect the opposite. Every team has to field a full roster, and that cost doesn't shrink with revenue, so lower-revenue teams should end up spending a bigger share of their money on players, not a smaller one. Instead, the 15 lowest-revenue teams put 43% into payroll on average, against 53% for the 15 highest.
And spending less didn't mean making less. The Marlins spent the smallest share in baseball, 27%, and still made $53 million, tied for fourth-most. Cleveland, Pittsburgh and the Athletics were also among the most profitable clubs.
Keeping payroll low, collecting revenue-sharing money and turning a profit is what fans call tanking. Not every low spender does it; Milwaukee and Tampa Bay spend a low share and still win. But a club near the top in profit and near the bottom in spending isn't short of money. Keeping payroll that low is an ownership choice.
The more of their revenue teams spend on players, the less they keep. The lowest spenders mostly turn a profit.
Left 8, highest payroll share: 7 of 8 lost money, about $401 million combined.
Right 8, lowest payroll share: 7 of 8 made a profit, $295 million combined.
See the numbers as a table
| Team | MLB proposal group | Revenue | Payroll | Payroll % of revenue | Operating income |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Los Angeles Dodgers | Would have to cut payroll (cap list) | $850M | $417M | 49% | $-20M |
| New York Yankees | Would have to cut payroll (cap list) | $710M | $320M | 45% | $-53M |
| Chicago Cubs | Would have to cut payroll (cap list) | $599M | $231M | 39% | $58M |
| Boston Red Sox | Would have to cut payroll (cap list) | $567M | $249M | 44% | $78M |
| New York Mets | Would have to cut payroll (cap list) | $553M | $347M | 63% | $-213M |
| Philadelphia Phillies | Would have to cut payroll (cap list) | $539M | $314M | 58% | $-52M |
| Atlanta Braves | Between floor and cap | $524M | $235M | 45% | $27M |
| San Francisco Giants | Between floor and cap | $477M | $225M | 47% | $54M |
| Houston Astros | Between floor and cap | $464M | $246M | 53% | $-45M |
| San Diego Padres | Would have to cut payroll (cap list) | $452M | $270M | 60% | $-1M |
| Toronto Blue Jays | Would have to cut payroll (cap list) | $445M | $286M | 64% | $-71M |
| Texas Rangers | Between floor and cap | $398M | $241M | 61% | $-44M |
| Seattle Mariners | Between floor and cap | $390M | $194M | 50% | $24M |
| Los Angeles Angels | Between floor and cap | $377M | $221M | 59% | $-14M |
| Detroit Tigers | Between floor and cap | $363M | $188M | 52% | $27M |
| Baltimore Orioles | Between floor and cap | $355M | $179M | 51% | $23M |
| Milwaukee Brewers | Would have to add payroll (floor list) | $354M | $144M | 41% | $47M |
| St. Louis Cardinals | Would have to add payroll (floor list) | $350M | $154M | 44% | $33M |
| Cleveland Guardians | Would have to add payroll (floor list) | $337M | $128M | 38% | $53M |
| Cincinnati Reds | Would have to add payroll (floor list) | $336M | $144M | 43% | $26M |
| Kansas City Royals | Between floor and cap | $330M | $181M | 55% | $25M |
| Pittsburgh Pirates | Would have to add payroll (floor list) | $330M | $109M | 33% | $48M |
| Arizona Diamondbacks | Between floor and cap | $324M | $216M | 67% | $-31M |
| Athletics | Would have to add payroll (floor list) | $320M | $118M | 37% | $45M |
| Miami Marlins | Would have to add payroll (floor list) | $320M | $87M | 27% | $53M |
| Colorado Rockies | Would have to add payroll (floor list) | $319M | $147M | 46% | $20M |
| Minnesota Twins | Would have to add payroll (floor list) | $315M | $142M | 45% | $11M |
| Washington Nationals | Would have to add payroll (floor list) | $300M | $134M | 45% | $-15M |
| Tampa Bay Rays | Would have to add payroll (floor list) | $290M | $103M | 36% | $31M |
| Chicago White Sox | Would have to add payroll (floor list) | $239M | $92M | 38% | $-40M |
What it means for us: a salary cap limits the teams with the biggest payrolls. It doesn't change anything for the teams at the bottom of this chart, whose owners decide how much of their revenue goes to the team. Which part of MLB's plan speaks to low spending: the cap, or the floor?
Does a higher payroll buy playoff trips?
When we fans talk about winning, we mean making it to October: did we make the playoffs, and did we go deep? Across 2017 to 2026, a team's average payroll and its number of playoff appearances were only moderately related (correlation 0.42). Look at the teams far from the dashed line: Milwaukee (8 trips), Cleveland (7) and Tampa Bay (6) sat near the bottom in payroll, while the Angels spent in the top dozen and never made it once.
And once they get there?
Payroll is more closely tied to winning playoff series (correlation 0.58), driven mostly by the Dodgers and Astros. But only 4 of the last 10 champions had a top-five payroll, and the 2026 World Series was played between two teams below MLB's proposed floor.
See the numbers as a table
| Team | Avg payroll, 2017 to 2026 | Winning seasons | Playoff trips | Playoff series won | Titles |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Los Angeles Dodgers | $291M | 10 | 10 | 18 | 3 |
| New York Yankees | $264M | 10 | 9 | 10 | 0 |
| New York Mets | $264M | 4 | 2 | 2 | 0 |
| Boston Red Sox | $228M | 6 | 5 | 5 | 1 |
| Philadelphia Phillies | $225M | 6 | 5 | 5 | 0 |
| Chicago Cubs | $215M | 8 | 5 | 2 | 0 |
| Houston Astros | $214M | 8 | 9 | 14 | 2 |
| Toronto Blue Jays | $206M | 5 | 4 | 2 | 0 |
| San Diego Padres | $205M | 6 | 5 | 5 | 0 |
| Atlanta Braves | $202M | 8 | 8 | 6 | 1 |
| San Francisco Giants | $200M | 1 | 1 | 0 | 0 |
| Los Angeles Angels | $197M | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0 |
| Texas Rangers | $189M | 1 | 1 | 4 | 1 |
| St. Louis Cardinals | $176M | 7 | 4 | 1 | 0 |
| Washington Nationals | $167M | 3 | 2 | 4 | 1 |
| Seattle Mariners | $161M | 6 | 2 | 2 | 0 |
| Colorado Rockies | $160M | 2 | 2 | 1 | 0 |
| Arizona Diamondbacks | $160M | 6 | 2 | 4 | 0 |
| Detroit Tigers | $153M | 2 | 2 | 2 | 0 |
| Minnesota Twins | $151M | 5 | 4 | 1 | 0 |
| Chicago White Sox | $142M | 3 | 3 | 1 | 0 |
| Kansas City Royals | $139M | 2 | 1 | 1 | 0 |
| Milwaukee Brewers | $136M | 9 | 8 | 5 | 1 |
| Cincinnati Reds | $134M | 4 | 2 | 0 | 0 |
| Baltimore Orioles | $128M | 3 | 2 | 0 | 0 |
| Cleveland Guardians | $119M | 8 | 7 | 3 | 0 |
| Miami Marlins | $106M | 2 | 2 | 1 | 0 |
| Tampa Bay Rays | $105M | 7 | 6 | 6 | 0 |
| Athletics | $100M | 4 | 3 | 1 | 0 |
| Pittsburgh Pirates | $96M | 2 | 0 | 0 | 0 |
So what about your team?
Pick your team to see what these numbers say. Are they held back by what they earn, or by how much of their revenue the owner puts back into the team?
Arizona Diamondbacks
Large market The Diamondbacks play in the 11th-biggest of 27 MLB metro areas. MLB counts them as large market.
Points to the money gap
The Diamondbacks' owner spends; the limit is what they earn
The Diamondbacks spend 67% of their revenue on payroll (1st of 30), more than any other team, but bring in $324 million, 23rd of 30. They made 2 playoff trips in the last 10 seasons. Diamondbacks fans have reason to be frustrated: the owner spends, and the team still falls behind. A cap could help here by limiting how far richer teams outspend the Diamondbacks. But both sides have already proposed sending more money to lower-revenue clubs: owners by pooling local TV money, players by guaranteeing more revenue to small-market clubs. If more shared revenue can close the gap, should we lose games over a cap?
MLB's plan puts the Diamondbacks between the floor and the cap: neither would change their payroll today.
Athletics
Small market The A's play in the 22nd-biggest of 27 MLB metro areas. MLB counts them as small market.
Points to ownership
The numbers fit the pattern fans call tanking
The A's spend 37% of their revenue on payroll (27th of 30), less than most, and Forbes estimates they made $45 million in 2025, 8th in baseball. They made 3 playoff trips in the last 10 seasons. Low payroll, steady profit, few trips to October: fans call this pattern tanking. A cap only limits the biggest spenders, so it wouldn't raise the A's' payroll. Only the owner, or a salary floor that requires it, would.
MLB's plan puts the A's on the floor list: the floor, not the cap, is the part that would make them spend more.
Atlanta Braves
Large market The Braves play in the 7th-biggest of 27 MLB metro areas. MLB counts them as large market.
Spending and winning
The Braves spend, and it shows in October
The Braves spend 45% of their revenue on payroll (18th of 30) and made 8 playoff trips in the last 10 seasons. Spending more of what they earn has paid off for them.
MLB's plan puts the Braves between the floor and the cap: neither would change their payroll today.
Baltimore Orioles
Small market The Orioles play in the 20th-biggest of 27 MLB metro areas. MLB counts them as small market.
Points to the money gap
The Orioles' owner spends; the limit is what they earn
The Orioles spend 51% of their revenue on payroll (11th of 30), more than most, but bring in $355 million, 16th of 30. They made 2 playoff trips in the last 10 seasons. Orioles fans have reason to be frustrated: the owner spends, and the team still falls behind. A cap could help here by limiting how far richer teams outspend the Orioles. But both sides have already proposed sending more money to lower-revenue clubs: owners by pooling local TV money, players by guaranteeing more revenue to small-market clubs. If more shared revenue can close the gap, should we lose games over a cap?
MLB's plan puts the Orioles between the floor and the cap: neither would change their payroll today.
Boston Red Sox
Large market The Red Sox play in the 12th-biggest of 27 MLB metro areas. MLB counts them as large market.
A cap would limit your team
A cap would cut the Red Sox' payroll
The Red Sox spend 44% of their revenue on payroll (20th of 30), and Forbes estimates they made $78 million in 2025, 1st in baseball. They're one of the 8 teams MLB says would have to cut payroll to fit under the cap. Cutting payroll can mean trading a star or not chasing top free agents the way they can today. They made 5 playoff trips in the last 10 seasons.
MLB's plan puts the Red Sox on the cap list: they would have to cut payroll.
Chicago Cubs
Large market The Cubs play in the 3rd-biggest of 27 MLB metro areas. MLB counts them as large market.
A cap would limit your team
A cap would cut the Cubs' payroll, even though they already spend a smaller share than most
The Cubs spend 39% of their revenue on payroll (24th of 30), and Forbes estimates they made $58 million in 2025, 2nd in baseball. The money to compete is there. MLB's plan would put a ceiling on it, which can mean trading a star or sitting out free agency. They made 5 playoff trips in the last 10 seasons.
MLB's plan puts the Cubs on the cap list: they would have to cut payroll.
Chicago White Sox
Large market The White Sox play in the 3rd-biggest of 27 MLB metro areas. MLB counts them as large market.
Mixed
Tight money, and a low share going to payroll
The White Sox bring in $239 million (30th of 30) and spend 38% of their revenue on payroll (25th of 30). Forbes estimates they had a $40 million loss in 2025. They made 3 playoff trips in the last 10 seasons. The numbers show both: less money than most, and less of it going to players. A floor would require more spending; a cap on other teams wouldn't touch either.
MLB's plan puts the White Sox on the floor list: the floor, not the cap, is the part that would make them spend more.
Cincinnati Reds
Small market The Reds play in the 24th-biggest of 27 MLB metro areas. MLB counts them as small market.
Points to ownership
The numbers fit the pattern fans call tanking
The Reds spend 43% of their revenue on payroll (22nd of 30), less than most, and Forbes estimates they made $26 million in 2025, 13th in baseball. They made 2 playoff trips in the last 10 seasons. Low payroll, steady profit, few trips to October: fans call this pattern tanking. A cap only limits the biggest spenders, so it wouldn't raise the Reds' payroll. Only the owner, or a salary floor that requires it, would.
MLB's plan puts the Reds on the floor list: the floor, not the cap, is the part that would make them spend more.
Cleveland Guardians
Small market The Guardians play in the 26th-biggest of 27 MLB metro areas. MLB counts them as small market.
Points to ownership
Winning, with room to spend more
The Guardians spend 38% of their revenue on payroll (26th of 30), less than most, and Forbes estimates they made $53 million in 2025, 4th in baseball. They still made 7 playoff trips in the last 10 seasons, so the front office does a lot with what it gets. The numbers say the owner could afford to put more into the team. A cap wouldn't raise the Guardians' payroll; only the owner, or a salary floor, would.
MLB's plan puts the Guardians on the floor list: the floor, not the cap, is the part that would make them spend more.
Colorado Rockies
Small market The Rockies play in the 19th-biggest of 27 MLB metro areas. MLB counts them as small market.
Points to the money gap
The Rockies' owner spends; the limit is what they earn
The Rockies spend 46% of their revenue on payroll (15th of 30), about the league middle, but bring in $319 million, 26th of 30. They made 2 playoff trips in the last 10 seasons. Rockies fans have reason to be frustrated: the owner spends, and the team still falls behind. A cap could help here by limiting how far richer teams outspend the Rockies. But both sides have already proposed sending more money to lower-revenue clubs: owners by pooling local TV money, players by guaranteeing more revenue to small-market clubs. If more shared revenue can close the gap, should we lose games over a cap?
MLB's plan puts the Rockies on the floor list: the floor, not the cap, is the part that would make them spend more.
Detroit Tigers
Small market The Tigers play in the 14th-biggest of 27 MLB metro areas. MLB counts them as small market.
Points to how the team is run
Money isn't what's holding the Tigers back
The Tigers bring in $363 million (15th of 30) and spend 52% of their revenue on payroll (10th of 30), more than most. Yet they made only 2 playoff trips in the last 10 seasons. The numbers point to how the money is spent, not how much there is. A cap limits how much a team can spend, not how well it spends.
MLB's plan puts the Tigers between the floor and the cap: neither would change their payroll today.
Houston Astros
Large market The Astros play in the 5th-biggest of 27 MLB metro areas. MLB counts them as large market.
Spending and winning
The Astros spend, and it shows in October
The Astros spend 53% of their revenue on payroll (9th of 30) and made 9 playoff trips in the last 10 seasons. Spending more of what they earn has paid off for them.
MLB's plan puts the Astros between the floor and the cap: neither would change their payroll today.
Kansas City Royals
Small market The Royals play in the 25th-biggest of 27 MLB metro areas. MLB counts them as small market.
Points to the money gap
The Royals' owner spends; the limit is what they earn
The Royals spend 55% of their revenue on payroll (8th of 30), more than most, but bring in $330 million, 21st of 30. They made 1 playoff trip in the last 10 seasons. Royals fans have reason to be frustrated: the owner spends, and the team still falls behind. A cap could help here by limiting how far richer teams outspend the Royals. But both sides have already proposed sending more money to lower-revenue clubs: owners by pooling local TV money, players by guaranteeing more revenue to small-market clubs. If more shared revenue can close the gap, should we lose games over a cap?
MLB's plan puts the Royals between the floor and the cap: neither would change their payroll today.
Los Angeles Angels
Large market The Angels play in the 2nd-biggest of 27 MLB metro areas. MLB counts them as large market.
Points to how the team is run
Money isn't what's holding the Angels back
The Angels bring in $377 million (14th of 30) and spend 59% of their revenue on payroll (6th of 30), more than most. Yet they haven't made the playoffs in the last 10 seasons. The numbers point to how the money is spent, not how much there is. A cap limits how much a team can spend, not how well it spends.
MLB's plan puts the Angels between the floor and the cap: neither would change their payroll today.
Los Angeles Dodgers
Large market The Dodgers play in the 2nd-biggest of 27 MLB metro areas. MLB counts them as large market.
A cap would limit your team
A cap would cut the Dodgers' payroll
The Dodgers spend 49% of their revenue on payroll (13th of 30), and Forbes estimates they had a $20 million loss in 2025. They're one of the 8 teams MLB says would have to cut payroll to fit under the cap. Cutting payroll can mean trading a star or not chasing top free agents the way they can today. They made 10 playoff trips in the last 10 seasons.
MLB's plan puts the Dodgers on the cap list: they would have to cut payroll.
Miami Marlins
Large market The Marlins play in the 9th-biggest of 27 MLB metro areas. MLB counts them as large market.
Points to ownership
The numbers fit the pattern fans call tanking
The Marlins spend 27% of their revenue on payroll (30th of 30), less than any other team, and Forbes estimates they made $53 million in 2025, 5th in baseball. They made 2 playoff trips in the last 10 seasons. Low payroll, steady profit, few trips to October: fans call this pattern tanking. A cap only limits the biggest spenders, so it wouldn't raise the Marlins' payroll. Only the owner, or a salary floor that requires it, would.
MLB's plan puts the Marlins on the floor list: the floor, not the cap, is the part that would make them spend more.
Milwaukee Brewers
Small market The Brewers play in the smallest of 27 MLB metro areas. MLB counts them as small market.
Points to ownership
Winning, with room to spend more
The Brewers spend 41% of their revenue on payroll (23rd of 30), less than most, and Forbes estimates they made $47 million in 2025, 7th in baseball. They still made 8 playoff trips in the last 10 seasons, so the front office does a lot with what it gets. The numbers say the owner could afford to put more into the team. A cap wouldn't raise the Brewers' payroll; only the owner, or a salary floor, would.
MLB's plan puts the Brewers on the floor list: the floor, not the cap, is the part that would make them spend more.
Minnesota Twins
Small market The Twins play in the 16th-biggest of 27 MLB metro areas. MLB counts them as small market.
Points to the money gap
The Twins' owner spends; the limit is what they earn
The Twins spend 45% of their revenue on payroll (17th of 30), about the league middle, but bring in $315 million, 27th of 30. They made 4 playoff trips in the last 10 seasons. Twins fans have reason to be frustrated: the owner spends, and the team still falls behind. A cap could help here by limiting how far richer teams outspend the Twins. But both sides have already proposed sending more money to lower-revenue clubs: owners by pooling local TV money, players by guaranteeing more revenue to small-market clubs. If more shared revenue can close the gap, should we lose games over a cap?
MLB's plan puts the Twins on the floor list: the floor, not the cap, is the part that would make them spend more.
New York Mets
Large market The Mets play in the biggest of 27 MLB metro areas. MLB counts them as large market.
A cap would limit your team
A cap would cut the Mets' payroll
The Mets spend 63% of their revenue on payroll (3rd of 30), and Forbes estimates they had a $213 million loss in 2025. They're one of the 8 teams MLB says would have to cut payroll to fit under the cap. Cutting payroll can mean trading a star or not chasing top free agents the way they can today. They made 2 playoff trips in the last 10 seasons.
MLB's plan puts the Mets on the cap list: they would have to cut payroll.
New York Yankees
Large market The Yankees play in the biggest of 27 MLB metro areas. MLB counts them as large market.
A cap would limit your team
A cap would cut the Yankees' payroll
The Yankees spend 45% of their revenue on payroll (16th of 30), and Forbes estimates they had a $53 million loss in 2025. They're one of the 8 teams MLB says would have to cut payroll to fit under the cap. Cutting payroll can mean trading a star or not chasing top free agents the way they can today. They made 9 playoff trips in the last 10 seasons.
MLB's plan puts the Yankees on the cap list: they would have to cut payroll.
Philadelphia Phillies
Large market The Phillies play in the 10th-biggest of 27 MLB metro areas. MLB counts them as large market.
A cap would limit your team
A cap would cut the Phillies' payroll
The Phillies spend 58% of their revenue on payroll (7th of 30), and Forbes estimates they had a $52 million loss in 2025. They're one of the 8 teams MLB says would have to cut payroll to fit under the cap. Cutting payroll can mean trading a star or not chasing top free agents the way they can today. They made 5 playoff trips in the last 10 seasons.
MLB's plan puts the Phillies on the cap list: they would have to cut payroll.
Pittsburgh Pirates
Small market The Pirates play in the 23rd-biggest of 27 MLB metro areas. MLB counts them as small market.
Points to ownership
The numbers fit the pattern fans call tanking
The Pirates spend 33% of their revenue on payroll (29th of 30), less than most, and Forbes estimates they made $48 million in 2025, 6th in baseball. They haven't made the playoffs in the last 10 seasons. Low payroll, steady profit, few trips to October: fans call this pattern tanking. A cap only limits the biggest spenders, so it wouldn't raise the Pirates' payroll. Only the owner, or a salary floor that requires it, would.
MLB's plan puts the Pirates on the floor list: the floor, not the cap, is the part that would make them spend more.
San Diego Padres
Small market The Padres play in the 18th-biggest of 27 MLB metro areas. MLB counts them as small market.
A cap would limit your team
A cap would cut the Padres' payroll
The Padres spend 60% of their revenue on payroll (5th of 30), and Forbes estimates they had a $1 million loss in 2025. They're one of the 8 teams MLB says would have to cut payroll to fit under the cap. Cutting payroll can mean trading a star or not chasing top free agents the way they can today. They made 5 playoff trips in the last 10 seasons.
MLB's plan puts the Padres on the cap list: they would have to cut payroll.
San Francisco Giants
Small market The Giants play in the 13th-biggest of 27 MLB metro areas. MLB counts them as small market.
Points to how the team is run
Money isn't what's holding the Giants back
The Giants bring in $477 million (8th of 30) and spend 47% of their revenue on payroll (14th of 30), about the league middle. Yet they made only 1 playoff trip in the last 10 seasons. The numbers point to how the money is spent, not how much there is. A cap limits how much a team can spend, not how well it spends.
MLB's plan puts the Giants between the floor and the cap: neither would change their payroll today.
Seattle Mariners
Small market The Mariners play in the 15th-biggest of 27 MLB metro areas. MLB counts them as small market.
Points to how the team is run
Money isn't what's holding the Mariners back
The Mariners bring in $390 million (13th of 30) and spend 50% of their revenue on payroll (12th of 30), more than most. Yet they made only 2 playoff trips in the last 10 seasons. The numbers point to how the money is spent, not how much there is. A cap limits how much a team can spend, not how well it spends.
MLB's plan puts the Mariners between the floor and the cap: neither would change their payroll today.
St. Louis Cardinals
Small market The Cardinals play in the 21st-biggest of 27 MLB metro areas. MLB counts them as small market.
Points to ownership
The money is there; less of it goes to the Cardinals
The Cardinals spend 44% of their revenue on payroll (21st of 30), less than most, and Forbes estimates they made $33 million in 2025, 9th in baseball. They made 4 playoff trips in the last 10 seasons. The limit here isn't revenue, it's how much of it the owner chooses to spend. A cap wouldn't raise the Cardinals' payroll; only the owner, or a salary floor, would.
MLB's plan puts the Cardinals on the floor list: the floor, not the cap, is the part that would make them spend more.
Tampa Bay Rays
Small market The Rays play in the 17th-biggest of 27 MLB metro areas. MLB counts them as small market.
Points to ownership
Winning, with room to spend more
The Rays spend 36% of their revenue on payroll (28th of 30), less than most, and Forbes estimates they made $31 million in 2025, 10th in baseball. They still made 6 playoff trips in the last 10 seasons, so the front office does a lot with what it gets. The numbers say the owner could afford to put more into the team. A cap wouldn't raise the Rays' payroll; only the owner, or a salary floor, would.
MLB's plan puts the Rays on the floor list: the floor, not the cap, is the part that would make them spend more.
Texas Rangers
Large market The Rangers play in the 4th-biggest of 27 MLB metro areas. MLB counts them as large market.
Points to how the team is run
Money isn't what's holding the Rangers back
The Rangers bring in $398 million (12th of 30) and spend 61% of their revenue on payroll (4th of 30), more than most. Yet they made only 1 playoff trip in the last 10 seasons. The numbers point to how the money is spent, not how much there is. A cap limits how much a team can spend, not how well it spends.
MLB's plan puts the Rangers between the floor and the cap: neither would change their payroll today.
Toronto Blue Jays
Large market The Blue Jays play in the 6th-biggest of 27 MLB metro areas. MLB counts them as large market.
A cap would limit your team
A cap would cut the Blue Jays' payroll
The Blue Jays spend 64% of their revenue on payroll (2nd of 30), and Forbes estimates they had a $71 million loss in 2025. They're one of the 8 teams MLB says would have to cut payroll to fit under the cap. Cutting payroll can mean trading a star or not chasing top free agents the way they can today. They made 4 playoff trips in the last 10 seasons.
MLB's plan puts the Blue Jays on the cap list: they would have to cut payroll.
Washington Nationals
Large market The Nationals play in the 8th-biggest of 27 MLB metro areas. MLB counts them as large market.
Points to the money gap
The Nationals' owner spends; the limit is what they earn
The Nationals spend 45% of their revenue on payroll (19th of 30), about the league middle, but bring in $300 million, 28th of 30. They made 2 playoff trips in the last 10 seasons. Nationals fans have reason to be frustrated: the owner spends, and the team still falls behind. A cap could help here by limiting how far richer teams outspend the Nationals. But both sides have already proposed sending more money to lower-revenue clubs: owners by pooling local TV money, players by guaranteeing more revenue to small-market clubs. If more shared revenue can close the gap, should we lose games over a cap?
MLB's plan puts the Nationals on the floor list: the floor, not the cap, is the part that would make them spend more.
This is a read of these numbers only: Forbes estimates of each team's 2025 revenue and profit, its final 2025 luxury-tax payroll, and its record from 2017 to 2026. It can't see inside a front office, so treat it as a starting point and decide for yourself. Market size is metro-area population (US Census Bureau, 2025; Toronto: Statistics Canada). MLB doesn't publish which teams it calls large market. Its numbers match counting the 12 biggest metro areas as large and everyone else as small. With only two groups, the Giants (13th-biggest metro) count as small market, the same as the Brewers (smallest), whose metro is about a third the size.
So where does that leave us?
Money helps, especially in the playoffs. But the numbers show two things a cap doesn't touch: some owners put a much smaller share of their revenue into the team, and how a team is run matters about as much as what it spends when it comes to playoff trips and titles. For teams whose owners already spend most of what comes in, like Kansas City and Arizona, the gap is revenue, and both sides have proposed sending more money to lower-revenue clubs. None of these fixes needs a cap. Should we lose games over one?
How we built this: revenue, operating income and player costs are Forbes estimates for the 2025 season, since teams don't publish their finances. Payroll is each team's final 2025 luxury-tax payroll, which includes about $19 million of benefits per club. Ten-season figures use Spotrac luxury-tax payrolls and MLB's official standings and postseason results. Correlation runs from 0 (no relationship) to 1 (perfect).
Sources
- Forbes: MLB team valuations 2026 (team revenue, operating income and player expenses for the 2025 season)
- AP: Final 2025 MLB luxury-tax payrolls
- Spotrac: MLB luxury-tax payrolls, 2017 to 2026
- MLB Stats API: standings and postseason results, 2017 to 2026
- MLB: Baseball's payroll disparity problem explained (Nov 14, 2026)
- US Census Bureau: Metropolitan area population estimates, 2025
- MLB: Fact Sheet, Transition Proposal (cap and floor team lists)
Last updated