Opinion: Nobody caps your paycheck
This is an opinion column. Most working Americans would not accept a rule limiting what their employer may pay them, while the company's own earnings stay unlimited. A hard salary cap asks baseball players to accept exactly that rule, and it is why many fans see a cap as a bad deal, not a fair one.
Imagine your company announced a rule: no matter how well you perform, no matter how much the business grows, the total paid to everyone on your team can never pass a fixed number. If you get a raise, a coworker takes a cut. Meanwhile there's no limit on what the owners keep.
Few people would sign a deal like that. Yet a hard salary cap asks baseball players for exactly that deal, and it is being sold to fans as fairness.
In a free market, pay follows value. Players are paid well because millions of us buy tickets, watch games and wear the jersey. Capping their pay doesn't send that money back to us. It sends it to the owners.
To be fair about it: NFL, NBA and NHL players do work under caps, and their unions agreed to them. Each league had its own reasons, and none of them apply to baseball today. Baseball has thrived for 150 years without a cap. There's no reason to start now.
— Sonny, a fan
Last updated